When one of the world's largest
manufacturers of consumer electronics sustained damage to
their distribution center near Mexico City, some $1 million
in merchandise suffered water damage.
Complicating matters were product
labeling that precluded importing to the U.S., complex tax
issues and the financial relationship between the Mexican
unit of the U.K. insurer and its Korean re-insurer.
Our experienced team successfully
navigated to a solution that brought about a competitive bid
sale in Mexico, with proceeds of better than 50%, cutting
the stock loss in half.
When
numerous floating casino barges along the Mississippi Gulf
Coast were deemed a total loss as the result of Hurricane Katrina,
their contents were turned over to salvage companies to be
sold for the account of the insuring companies. In most
cases, these contents were sold for a lump sum price, with
the buyer acquiring "mining rights" to the
property.
With replacement costs estimated in the
millions, we received and rejected such offers, and elected
to invest about $50,000.00 to stabilize, clean and protect
the highest valued electronic equipment. After thorough
research, we then grouped the highest dollar contents into
multiple lots and conducted on-site bid sales on each one.
The results were successful, and the interest and traffic
generated from these sales also enabled us to negotiate
additional salvage sales for the minor - but still important
- residual portions of the contents.
The resultant recovery was the highest
dollar per square foot of any of the casino barges.
When
this electrical warehouse burned, the insurance company was
told that "absolutely nothing is left, and demolition
needs to get underway immediately". The insurer's
highly experienced adjuster asked us to come in to examine
the remains, and we literally dug into the debris,
discovering tons of valuable copper and aluminum wire and
cable.
We brought in the people, equipment and
transport needed to recover the material, contracted for
smelting and refining, and at the end of a few short months,
sent over $825,000.00 to the insurance company from their
"complete and total loss."
Not long ago, we were called to the scene of a devastating
flood loss at the service center of a major metals company. Some
10 thousand tons of coiled and sheeted steel and aluminum
were stored within the plant awaiting processing to customer
specifications, and roughly one-third of the stock had been
either completely or partially submerged in the silt-laden
water. High air temperatures at the time of, and subsequent
to the flooding, had created a saturated environment, and
day-night temperature cycles produced heavy condensation on
the "above the water-line" materials, with
attendant osmosis promoting the movement of water into the
laps of the coils and between the sheets of processed
material.
The insured purchased material for
processing to customer specifications, and bought little or
none on a speculative basis. In other words, almost their
entire inventory had a future home - a specific customer who
required specific product for their manufacturing
applications. The liquidation of this stock, even if
undamaged, into the general marketplace, with the attendant
costs of loading, shipping and integrating into another
center's inventory for processing and sale, would have forced
significant discounting.
With this in mind, it made sense to consider alternatives to the total
liquidation of all material. Certain customers had sourcing
problems, and their end-use allowed less than pristine
surfaces (e.g. heavy plate), such that the product could be,
literally, hosed off prior to shipment. Another customer
used aluminum sheets whose imperfect finish was acceptable
for their applications, and a cooperative competing service
center was willing to do the work on the insured's coils and
fill the customer's requirements with material that was
above the water line. Likewise, much of the structural steel
was able to go to its intended customers after washing down.
Ultimately, we did liquidate, in a
measured and orderly fashion, about half of the product,
recovering some 50% of its original value, while the added
expense and discounting of the other half cost only around
10% of its value. In sum, the loss to the stock, in its
entirety, came to only 30%, not much different from what
would have resulted from the liquidation of a mirror-image
undamaged stock.
This case high-lights the importance of
considering the alternatives to liquidation of property into
the salvage markets, including but not limited to: separation
of stock not actually degraded by the event, restoration,
rework or reprocessing and/or discounting for sale into
existing markets.
When
a top-quality motor coach manufacturer sustained smoke and
soot damage to 25 brand new coaches, the insured removed
all warranties and these “Refurbished Vehicles”
totaling nearly $4.3 million in insured value were turned
over to Stoner & Company to be sold “as-is”.
We started by separating the stock into 5 lots to maximize
the sale. Then, by utilizing the REAL value of the internet
for insurance salvage – buyer research and notification
– buyers from across North America were sent comprehensive
bid packages and were invited to attend our online liquidation.
The results of our online liquidation: at least 11 serious
bids were received on each lot with the final sale of $3.92
million or over 90% of insured value! And both the insured
and the insurer were pleased that we were able to remit
all proceeds in less than 30 days from the date of loss.
|